2023 | Elisa Luckabaugh | University of Mary Washington |
| A.J. Heichelbech | University of Louisville |
| Miles Baker | Furman University |
| Oriana Ballotta | University of Richmond |
2022 | Cooper Corey | Univ. of Alabama |
| Caleb Dale | Samford Univ. |
2021 | Sanica Manglorkar | Georgia State Univ. |
| Lilian Hutchens | Univ. of South Carolina |
2020 | Sierra Moore | Virginia Tech |
2019 | Sarah Grumulaitis | Samford University |
2018 | Timothy K. Kinlaw | Appalachian State Univ. |
| Sarah Marie Van Schoick | Santa Fe College & University of Florida |
| Cody Perkins | Concord University |
2016 | Patrick Thomason | Samford University |
| Katie Testerman | Concord University |
2017 | Linnea Ryan | Armstrong State University |
| Alistair Andrulis | University of Mary Washington |
2015 | Elisa Sperandio | Concord University |
2014 | Nate Lawrence | Concord University |
| Ethan Bottone | Univ. of Mary Washington |
2013 | Paul Lemiuex | Univ. of Tennessee |
2012 | Taylor D. Holden | Univ. of Richmond |
| Vincent D. Walker | Univ. of South Alabama |
2010 | Zachary Wehrmann | Univ. of Mary Washington |